It's actually a basic mentalist trick - the numbers don't really do anything but distract your mind a bit, but when asked that question, most people will say carrot. There are a bunch of other examples of what people will usually say.
mine was not carrot. i got distracted by the quick switch after the question so I was not able to answer the question at all.
Seems your witchcraft does not work on the powerful broccoli eaters! Well... My name gets mish-mashed with broccoli, so that's why I thought of it...
mango ruined it for me by talking about it mango!!!!! anyway I thought carrot because of that but my second thought was potato
Dammit PONM, fruit is not a vegetable! -stamps failed on PONM's forehead- Back to 10th grade with ye!